Meow twice if you would like some dinner
As the train arrived at the main station today and people were starting to get out, I was waiting behind a woman with two dogs that weren't too good at waiting patiently. The woman was talking to her dogs, trying to get them to calm down. She spoke to them as if they were people: "Come on, settle down, stop being so impatient all the time. What did I tell you? Wait now, you just never really listen, do you?" One of the dogs looked at her a bit confused. Now I absolutely believe that dogs are intelligent creatures, but somehow I highly doubted that they were understanding what being more patient meant, or that they should listen more.
I find it hilarious how people try to have conversations with their pets. A friend of mine has a new kitten and she will squat down in the kitchen in front of the little cat and say: "What's wrong? Are you hungry? Ha? Do you want to eat something?" But surprisingly, the stupid kitten just does not answer. I was standing next to them in the kitchen, saying to the kitten: "Come on, answer her! Why don't you say something?" But it just won't. Animals can be so rude.
24 Comments:
Dr. Doolittle you are not! Tell the kittey it is the dinner and see if it talks then...then you will know if it is intelligent or not.
September 22, 2008 at 6:55 AM
Schallendes Gelächter....
Well written anecdote.
Mach's guet!
September 22, 2008 at 7:24 AM
My weiner dog so acts like he is human. it is a trip, that dog. and Cat thinks she owns all of us. and we all need to be bowing down before her almighty presence! haha!
Hope you had a great weekend, girl!
September 22, 2008 at 7:30 AM
Of course they speak our language Betts ... whether or not they choose to answer is entirely up to their mood on the day. My cat, for example, talks very eloquently with her claws. If I ignore her (ie. not talk away to her) she sneaks up by stealth and digs those sharp claws in until all of a sudden I am talking away. Mind you, it's probably just as well SOME words are more difficult than others to understand. If I am late with feeding, a large chunk of flesh is swiftly bitten out of my ankle.
If she wants to play or go out she howls plaintively. If I sneeze she races up to me and meows and rubs herself against my leg. Her way of saying "bless you."
It is all a matter of interpretation. *Meow*
September 22, 2008 at 7:34 AM
animals are more intelligent than humans give them credit for. of course they understand what we tell them! maybe not the words, although they do learn the meaning of certain words (ask a dog if he wants to go byebye, or a cat if she wants dinner, and they will start dancing). pets understand tone of voice better than words. they understand looks and growls actions.
the reason pets don't listen when you tell them to calm down is because they never grow up. they are emotionally always two years old.
they know the difference between right and wrong, but they can't help themselves.
they are like men in that regard.
September 22, 2008 at 8:11 AM
You believe all men are like two year old's SERA?
What is that with woman - are you mature double that age?
Nevermind, I regress.
September 22, 2008 at 8:44 AM
My cat is just plain crazy. I do talk to her like she is a person, but, I never expect an answer. Although, most of the time I am talking to her I can get her to meow back. I find myself constantly saying the same things to her anyway. Mainly just in a soothing tone to get her to purr or a loud voice to get her to startle. Depends on if I want to wind her up or not. It's easy to get her to be all jumpy, she is not very social and gets frightened easily. But, I love her to death. She also seems to have the same feelings for me. I know this, because she avoided my ex-wife like the plague and followed me around the house all the time. She still does, it appears I can do no wrong.
September 22, 2008 at 12:12 PM
We had to spell certain words, since our dog knew what "outside" and "food" and "car" meant. Intelligence yes. But to engage an animal in a deliberation concerning the animal's conduct - hmmmm. Luschtik...
September 22, 2008 at 5:29 PM
This is one of my pet (no pun intended) hates - people who treat animals as humans, and who assign them human characteristics. They seem to think the smaller and fluffier they are, the more human they are. It winds me up no end. They're just animals!
September 22, 2008 at 8:53 PM
who decided to start talking to animals like they are humans? I hear crazies speaking to their pets in baby talk. Those people are to be avoided at all costs and if we are lucky they will be slowly worked out of the gene pool.
September 23, 2008 at 2:23 AM
Mystic- They always seem to understand the language of food- that much is for sure.
Zee- Dankeschön- und gliichfalls!
Katie- Well, I think your wiener probably is actually human. I don't know any other dogs that are alcoholics and work at McDonalds.
Aggs- Right. Maybe we should just try a bit harder then to understand "Catish" or "Dogish"... You seem to.
Sera- So they don't only understand our language, but are also capable of dancing? Well, I guess that's more than can be said of some men. ;-)
Larry- Aww... that sounds like true love.
EM- Hahaha, that's like what parents do with kids... My parents used to say stuff in English or French sometimes when they didn't want us to understand. But somehow we would often still get the meaning.
SJ- I love how your pet hate actually is all about pets. That's very appropriate.
Jerry- Hahaha... I'm sure they only mean well. Although it usually does concern me a bit too.
September 23, 2008 at 5:34 AM
Hehe, ya they can understand some words but only after you make it part of an action. My mother got her dog used to the words hurry up. Which in this case meant go out and pee or whatever. I thought it was rather appropriate since it does get annoying when her dog just wanders around the yard looking for a place to go. It's got to be juuuust the right place. Which can take up to 20 minutes to find apparently. Unfortunately for them their brains just don't have the capacity to learn enough words that having a full on conversation with your pet is pretty meaningless. The people that do that tend to view their pets as their children. Always a bad thing.
September 23, 2008 at 6:48 AM
Avshar- Your mum's dog takes 20 minutes to decide where it would like to pee? Man, if I had a dog that slow, I would certainly teach it how to hurry up! But maybe a little slap on the bum would work better than explaining why it is really annoying to have to wait that long... :-)
September 23, 2008 at 7:53 AM
lol zee, i was being funny.
of course men aren't
emotionally like two-year-olds.
they just mature later than women
(about 50 years later).
September 23, 2008 at 2:24 PM
Well Sera - I might still have a chance then ... to mature.
You're sure a handful, meow.
September 23, 2008 at 3:35 PM
I've been seeing you for a while on YSFB blog and decide I would give you a read and see if I like what's going on over here.
September 23, 2008 at 4:45 PM
Oh I get annoyed when people talk to pets like their people. I know the whole b.s. about how talking to them makes them feel better but what about dressing them? I know if I was somebody's pet and they started dressing me then they'd better lock their doors or else I'm mauling them in their sleep.
September 24, 2008 at 11:12 AM
a complex topic. Dogs can make lonely senior citizens feel needed and loved, and senior citizens have time to dress their pets and dote on them. I tried an experiment in class today and asked individuals about their pets - it was the easiest way to get lots of laughter and conversation going.
September 25, 2008 at 2:59 AM
meow, meow.
September 25, 2008 at 3:16 AM
ROFLMAO :-))))
... got me thinking on us
sitting talking to a computer ;-)
September 25, 2008 at 6:59 AM
meow meow
Okay - I meowed. Where's my dinner? I'm hungry!!!!
Oh, and I talk to my cat all the time. He just looks at me like I'm crazy, then rubs against my boobs.
September 25, 2008 at 10:56 AM
If Ms Tink is not the center of attention all the time she begins to howl. Howl damn it.
Do you know what it's like listening to a midget hound howl grueling mournful cries for not having a good morning kiss 2 seconds after I step out of bed- at 5am?
If I say walk.. She'll get her leash or try too. I keep it in a lil higher than her or she'd be packing all the time.
If I say bath.. She'll hide.
If I say carrot.. She'll run to the kitchen and sit.
Incredibly cute.
September 26, 2008 at 2:02 AM
I was gonna say, of course they understand, they just like to mess with us, but I'm afraid it's what Sera said. Meow, I mean Woof...;-)
September 26, 2008 at 3:48 PM
Ace- Hello and welcome to my humble abode. Please make yourself at home. Cup of coffee?
YSB- If you were a pet, I guess we would know better than to mess with you then.
EM- I know what you mean. I guess for old, lonely people it's excusable to talk to their pets as if they were people.
Sera- Alright. Your dinner is coming up.
Anna-Lys- You talk to your computer? (Ok, I do too sometimes. I swear at it if it doesn't do what I want it to do.)
Callie- No need to get impatient there! Your dinner is on the table.
Blither- So if you say, "I'm just gonna walk to the kitchen to get a carrot before I have a bath" she would get all confused, get a leash and then hide in the kitchen?
A.decker- Great minds think alike.
September 28, 2008 at 1:15 AM
Post a Comment
<< Home